
The Hoxton, Williamsburg
Best for neighborhood dining, rooftop skyline views, and exploring Williamsburg on foot or by bike.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Hoxton, Williamsburg is a design-led 4-star Brooklyn hotel with chef-driven Israeli dining and a lively waterfront Williamsburg location; read this if you want a neighborhood, food-forward Brooklyn base. The Peninsula New York is a Fifth Avenue grand 5-star hotel with a full-service spa and indoor pool in Midtown Manhattan; read this if you want classic luxury close to MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
Updated · about 6.5 km apart

Best for neighborhood dining, rooftop skyline views, and exploring Williamsburg on foot or by bike.

Best for classic Midtown luxury, full-service spa treatments, and being steps from Fifth Avenue and MoMA.
When The Hoxton, Williamsburg wins: choose The Hoxton if you prioritise a younger, design-forward Brooklyn stay, easy access to Williamsburg nightlife, markets and the L train into Manhattan, plus multiple on-site Michael Solomonov restaurants and a rooftop grill.
When The Peninsula New York wins: choose The Peninsula for traditional grand-hotel service, spacious Beaux-Arts rooms, an indoor pool and a full-service spa, and the convenience of being on Fifth Avenue within walking distance of major Midtown museums and stores.
Bottom line: pick The Hoxton for neighbourhood character, food and skyline views from Brooklyn; pick The Peninsula New York for polished Midtown luxury, on-site wellness facilities, and classic Fifth Avenue location.
| Category | The Hoxton, Williamsburg | The Peninsula New York |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Industrial-chic, neighbourhood-focused Brooklyn hotel with lively dining venues | Beaux-Arts, grand Fifth Avenue luxury hotel with formal service |
| Location | Williamsburg waterfront (97 Wythe Ave) — near East River State Park and Bedford Ave L train | Midtown Manhattan (700 Fifth Avenue at 55th Street) — steps from 5th Avenue and MoMA |
| Size | 175 rooms, 10 floors | 219 guestrooms |
| Room types (examples) | Cosy Room; Roomy Room; Cosy Brooklyn View Room; Cosy Manhattan View Room | Grand Luxe King Room; Grand Room, 1 King Bed (Premier); Superior Room; Superior Suite; Junior Suite |
| Audience / age policy | Family-friendly; children of all ages welcome; min. check-in age 18 | All ages welcome (family-friendly); check-in min age: 21 (per supplier listing) |
| Pools | No on-site pool | Indoor pool (listed) |
| Restaurants & bars | Three on-site venues (K'Far, Laser Wolf rooftop, seasonal Jaffa Cocktail and Raw Bar) | Clement Restaurant plus 3 bars/lounges and 24-hour room service |
| Spa / wellness | No on-site spa or gym; discounted access to nearby fitness/spa options | Full-service spa, 24-hour health club/fitness facilities and sauna |
| Events & meetings | The Apartment meeting/events concept — five rooms, flexible layouts (capacity up to ~130 for whole space) | Five meeting rooms and banquet/meeting facilities (supplier listing) |
| Pet policy | Dog-friendly: one dog up to 40 lbs per room, no extra fee; cats not accepted | Pet policy: Pet fee listed (USD 150 per pet, per stay) in supplier listing |
| Transit access | One stop to Manhattan on the L train; free hotel bicycles; close to NYC Ferry | Central Midtown — short walks to multiple subway lines and pedestrian access to Midtown attractions |
The Hoxton sits on Wythe Avenue in waterfront Williamsburg, steps from parks, markets and music venues.
Choose The Hoxton if you want a Brooklyn neighbourhood base with local food and nightlife within walking distance.
The Peninsula New York occupies a prime Midtown Fifth Avenue address near MoMA and Rockefeller Center.
Choose The Peninsula for direct access to Midtown museums, theaters and Fifth Avenue shopping.
The Hoxton's 175 rooms are industrial-chic and compact, with a clear Cosy vs Roomy split.
The Hoxton focuses on stylish, efficient rooms aimed at neighbourhood explorers rather than long-stay luxury.
The Peninsula's 219 guestrooms offer larger, classic luxury accommodations and premium bedding.
The Peninsula is better suited when you want more traditional, full-service luxury rooms and suites in Midtown.
The Hoxton's food offering is centred on Michael Solomonov's Israeli-inspired outlets across the property.
The Hoxton is a strong pick if you want chef-driven, locally focused dining without leaving the hotel.
The Peninsula offers classic American dining and multiple bars with round-the-clock room service.
The Peninsula suits travellers who want a full-service, formal hotel dining programme in Midtown.
The Hoxton emphasises rooftop views and local exploration rather than in-house aquatic amenities.
Pick The Hoxton if rooftop dining and neighbourhood activity matter more than an on-site pool.
The Peninsula offers on-site wellness facilities including an indoor pool and a full-service spa.
The Peninsula is the clear choice for travellers who want on-site pool and spa facilities in Midtown.
The Hoxton leans on local Brooklyn nightlife and markets rather than in-house wellness facilities.
Good for guests who want to step into local nightlife and food scenes rather than rely on hotel leisure facilities.
The Peninsula provides in-house leisure with a more formal, hotel-centric nightlife and wellness offering.
Best for travellers who prioritise in-house spa, gym and classic hotel bars in a Midtown setting.

The Hoxton's trio of Michael Solomonov venues — including the rooftop Laser Wolf — puts neighborhood dining front and center.

The Peninsula provides a full-service spa, indoor pool and formal Fifth Avenue location for museum and shopping access.

The Hoxton places you steps from Smorgasburg, Domino Park and live-music venues in Williamsburg.

The Peninsula's multiple meeting rooms and banquet facilities suit corporate or formal events in Midtown.
The Hoxton, Williamsburg — it sits in the heart of Williamsburg with chef-led dining on-site and many bars, markets and live-music venues within easy walking distance.
The Peninsula New York has an indoor pool and a full-service spa; The Hoxton, Williamsburg does not have an on-site pool or spa.
Yes. The Hoxton welcomes children of all ages (with up to 12 children staying free sharing existing bedding); The Peninsula's supplier listing notes family-friendly policies and one child 11 or younger can stay free in some conditions.
The Peninsula New York — it’s on Fifth Avenue within short walking distance of MoMA, Rockefeller Center and Fifth Avenue shopping.
Explore how The Hoxton, Williamsburg stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·