
The Hoxton, Williamsburg
Best for social Brooklyn stays, rooftop dining, and easy access to Williamsburg nightlife and markets.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
The Hoxton, Williamsburg is a design-led 4-star Brooklyn hotel on Wythe Avenue focused on contemporary neighborhood social life; this guide is for travelers who want a lively, food-forward Brooklyn base. The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel is a storied 5-star Upper East Side hotel with old-New-York luxury and cultural ties; this guide is for travelers seeking classic service, proximity to major museums, and formal hotel amenities.
Updated

Best for social Brooklyn stays, rooftop dining, and easy access to Williamsburg nightlife and markets.

Best for traditional luxury, formal service, and walking access to Central Park and major museums.
When The Hoxton, Williamsburg wins: pick The Hoxton if you want a younger, sociable Brooklyn scene, rooftop dining by Chef Michael Solomonov, easy local transit to Manhattan, and a compact, design-forward room at a 4-star price point.
When The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel wins: choose The Carlyle for a classic Upper East Side luxury stay with formal service, a full-service spa, Bemelman's Bar and close walking access to the Metropolitan Museum of Art and Central Park.
Bottom line: both hotels have strong local personalities — The Hoxton is about Brooklyn lifestyle, food and nightlife; The Carlyle offers old-New-York formality, museum proximity and full-service hotel amenities. Your pick should hinge on whether neighborhood buzz or traditional luxury is more important for this trip.
| Category | The Hoxton, Williamsburg | The Carlyle, A Rosewood Hotel |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Industrial-chic, lively Brooklyn social scene | Art Deco, formal luxury with cultural cachet |
| Location | Williamsburg waterfront, steps from East River State Park and Bedford Ave L train | Upper East Side, about a 10-minute walk to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art |
| Size | 175 rooms in a single 10-floor building | 188 guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | Family-friendly; children welcome (primary check-in age 18) | All ages welcome (not adults-only) |
| Pools | No on-site pool | |
| Restaurants & bars | Three on-site venues (K'Far, Laser Wolf rooftop, seasonal Jaffa Cocktail & Raw Bar) | Multiple outlets including two restaurants and Bemelman's Bar; 24-hour room service available |
| Spa & wellness | No on-site spa; discounted access to nearby gym and spa options | Full-service spa and health club listed |
| Known for | Rooftop dining, Brooklyn nightlife, markets and cycling around Williamsburg | Old-New-York history, Bemelman's Bar, proximity to museums and Central Park |
| Pet policy | Dog-friendly (one dog up to 40 lbs per room, no fee); cats not accepted | Not published |
| Free WiFi | Yes — throughout | |
The Hoxton sits on Wythe Avenue in waterfront Williamsburg, within walking distance of local markets, parks and the Bedford Ave L station.
Choose The Hoxton for neighborhood access to Brooklyn food, music and waterfront walks.
The Carlyle is on East 76th Street on the Upper East Side, minutes from Central Park and major museums.
Choose The Carlyle for classic Manhattan sightseeing and easy walking access to museums and the park.
The Hoxton offers 175 industrial‑chic rooms in Cosy and Roomy categories.
The Hoxton’s rooms are compact, design-forward and built around neighborhood stays.
The Carlyle has 188 guestrooms with traditional luxury appointments.
The Carlyle offers classic luxury rooms with full hotel services and in-room conveniences.
Dining is a major part of The Hoxton’s draw, led by Michael Solomonov’s venues.
Pick The Hoxton if you want lively, casual-to-buzzy dining and a rooftop scene.
The Carlyle emphasizes formal dining and a classic bar scene.
Choose The Carlyle for traditional dining, formal bar experiences, and in-room service options.
The Hoxton’s rooftop restaurant and direct access to Williamsburg define its signature offering.
The Hoxton centers its experience on rooftop dining and neighbourhood exploration.
The Carlyle’s signature is full-service luxury and cultural proximity.
The Carlyle focuses on classic hotel services and proximity to cultural institutions.
The Hoxton leverages nearby gyms and a strong local nightlife.
The Hoxton is best if you plan to use neighborhood fitness options and go out for nightlife.
The Carlyle provides on-site wellness and a quieter, more formal evening scene.
The Carlyle suits travelers who want on-site wellness and quieter, refined evenings.

The Hoxton — rooftop Laser Wolf, K'Far and immediate access to Williamsburg nightlife and markets.

The Carlyle — walk to Central Park and the Metropolitan Museum of Art in minutes.

The Carlyle — full-service spa, valet, limo/town car service and formal concierge support.

The Hoxton — industrial-chic rooms, neighborhood bikes and social public spaces.
Both welcome families. The Hoxton is explicitly family-friendly with free stays for children sharing bedding and nearby parks and markets; The Carlyle accepts families too but is more traditional in style.
The Carlyle lists a full-service spa and health club on its supplier listing. The Hoxton does not have an on-site spa, fitness centre or pool and provides discounted access to nearby facilities.
The Hoxton accepts one dog per room (up to 40 lbs) with no extra fee; The Carlyle’s supplier listing mentions a pet fee but does not publish a full pet policy in the provided listing (Not published in detail).
The Carlyle — it’s within a short walk to the Metropolitan Museum of Art and close to Central Park; The Hoxton requires a short subway or ferry/transit trip into Manhattan.
Explore how The Hoxton, Williamsburg stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·